If you're planning a basement, you've probably heard of sheet piling and secant piling. They're the most common ways to hold back the ground around a basement (called basement retention). The process can be loud, stressful and expensive, and in a tight residential street it gets trickier still.

The first hurdle: pre-drilling beside a fence

One of the first things we noticed was the stress we were putting on a neighbour's 40-year-old fence. It wasn't looking happy.

The cause was pre-drilling. We had to drill down about 8 metres to make way for the sheet piles. On this site the groundwater is very high and the soil is sandy, so pre-drilling loosens the sand and it flows back into the hole.

When the auger comes up, the hole fills back in with sand and water, undermining the ground right next to the fence. The fence footings weren't deep (it's a standard fence, not a structural wall), so there wasn't enough support under them. The fence started to sag, twist and drop under its own weight.

It was a big lesson for us. We knew some of the fence line was piered (sitting on concrete piers) and some wasn't.

A fence on piers that reach firm ground stays put; a shallow footing next to a pre-drilled hole can drop and twist
A fence on piers that reach firm ground stays put; a shallow footing next to a pre-drilled hole can drop and twist

What we learned about pre-drilling

  • Ask about the neighbours' footings. Find out whether your neighbours' fences have decent footings, ideally piered. If not, you risk serious damage and expensive repairs.
  • Get pre-drilling in the quote. Many sheet piling contractors won't quote for it. They quote to push the piles in, and if a pile bends or breaks they come back with a variation. That's bad for contract administration, client expectations and the budget.
  • Choose your contractor with that in mind. Ours included pre-drilling in their original quote. That's real peace of mind, even if there are still variations for latent conditions (unknown ground conditions).

Because parts of the fence were struggling (with shallow or missing footings), we had to build a small platform and prepare for a controlled demolition. It's a reminder that site prep is about more than the hole you're digging.

Vibration: the real conversation with your neighbours

Sheet piling is often associated with vibration, and we were worried about it. (The main reference for setting up vibration monitoring is DIN 4150-3, a German standard.) So we bought our own vibration monitors, made by a company called Convergence Instruments.

VSEW_mk4 8g Wireless Vibration Meter with 24/7 Data Access
Monitor vibrations remotely with the VSEW_mk4 8g wireless vibration meter, including one year of 24/7 data collection service for continuous monitoring.

These small devices cost about $1,000 each and are worth every cent. They measure movement on three axes (X, Y and Z), upload the data to the cloud in real time, and give us a record of exactly what happened.

What we learned about managing vibration on this project:

  • The big machine made a difference. We used a large drill rig to push the sheets in, rather than hammering them. We only used the vibrating attachment for the last metre or so of each pile.
  • The numbers. The average vibration we saw was around 3.5 millimetres per second (mm/s). For context, DIN 4150-3 suggests about 3 to 8 mm/s for sensitive or heritage buildings and about 5 to 15 mm/s for houses, depending on the vibration frequency.
  • Tracking the rig was the worst part. The biggest spikes (up to 9 mm/s) didn't come from driving the piles. They came from the heavy machinery tracking across the ground.

We also had our geotech install and read their own monitoring devices. If a dispute ever arose, we wanted the expert to be the one placing and reading the equipment. Otherwise someone could argue that we, not being geotechnical engineers, had installed ours incorrectly.

We didn't rely on them alone, though. We spent time (and a video call) with Convergence Instruments setting up our own devices properly, so we could trust the real-time data in the cloud software, with no false readings.

Illustrative day of vibration monitor readings during sheet piling, with alert and limit lines, one peak over the alert level and lower peaks after pre-drilling.
Example data recorded from our Mk4 Convergence instruments - 2e-3 is 2mm/s. The green line is a 3.5mm/s alert threshold line we established.

The cost: sheet piling vs secant piles

There's more than one way to retain a basement, and the prices are very different. We briefly considered secant piles for this job. Here's how they compared:

Sheet piles and secant piles in plan
Sheet piles and secant piles in plan
  • Secant piles are large concrete piers drilled into the ground so they interlock. They make an almost waterproof wall with almost no vibration. The catch: they would have cost around $300,000 more on this project, and they take up more space.
  • Sheet piling is what we used: steel sheets driven into the ground. It's faster, cheaper and takes up less room. The catch: it can vibrate, and sheet piles are usually treated as temporary retention that holds the ground while the permanent basement walls are built.
  • The decision. For this project, saving around $300,000 and keeping more space in the basement was the right call. The quietest option is often the most expensive, but good planning can manage the downsides of a cheaper one.

Keeping the neighbours happy (as much as you can)

Beyond the money and machinery, a big part of this project is people. Noise was a concern: we measured a maximum of about 86 decibels.

That's loud, but not over the top for a construction site. The worst part for everyone, including the crew, wasn't the sound. It was the diesel exhaust from the drill rig.

We tried to be considerate. An arborist checked the trees and gave us a management plan to protect them. We even cut back a palm tree from a cherry picker so the rig's head and auger wouldn't get tangled in the fronds.

From here, we're setting up a shared calendar with the neighbours so they know about deliveries, concrete pumping and other noisy work in advance. Constant rain has made scheduling hard, but being upfront will make a big difference for everyone.

The retention is in the ground

The hardest phase is over. The sheet piling is in, and the big machines are being picked up. From here it's generally smaller machines and less disruptive work.

The sheet piling went well. Near the end we tried a bentonite and water mix (bentonite is a clay that acts as a lubricant), and it made a huge difference to friction. Just remember you'll have to deal with the bentonite later.

If you're planning a project like this:

  1. Make sure pre-drilling is in your quote to avoid variations after the contract is signed.
  2. Monitor vibration closely so you can prove you're within limits.
  3. Talk to your neighbours early and often.

It wasn't always easy, but the worst of the vibration work is behind us, and the site is ready for the next stage.

The "reasonably foreseeable" trap

If you're reviewing a quote and something feels off, here's a concept that could save you thousands: reasonably foreseeable costs.

Most Queensland contracts, including the QBCC New Home Construction Contract, only let the builder claim extra for latent conditions (things like rock or groundwater) if they couldn't reasonably have been foreseen from the site information available when you signed. Check the latent conditions clause in your contract.

The builder is the expert selling the service, so they're best placed to anticipate the risks. Do your part:

  • Disclose everything you know about the site in writing: every report and every test result.
  • After that, the builder needs to allow for all reasonably foreseeable costs in their quote.

The sensible way to handle uncertainty is with provisional sums (PS) and prime cost (PC) items. A provisional sum for something like "rock excavation" is the contractor saying: "You might need this. We're flagging it now, and here's our best estimate."

It's not perfect, because the final price isn't locked in. But it's far better than signing a contract that says nothing about rock and then receiving a $25,000 rock removal variation. If rock was a known possibility, that cost is arguably the builder's, but proving it after the fact means lawyers, letters and a lot of stress.

My strong recommendation: ask every question in writing before the contract is signed. Never assume the contractor sees the job the same way you do.

Why builders avoid PS and PC items

Most residential builders don't like using provisional sums and prime cost items, for two reasons.

First, they make a quote look higher. If you're comparing three builders, and one has a $50,000 provisional sum for rock excavation while the other two have buried that risk in a lump sum, the first builder looks more expensive, even though they're being more transparent.

Second, they add admin. Adjusting PS and PC items later means paperwork, reconciliation and more back-and-forth.

That's understandable, but leaving them out doesn't remove the risk. It moves it onto you, and it leaves the builder open to a claim that the cost was reasonably foreseeable.

So ask your builder to break the risky items down and put a number on each one. A quote that shows its provisional sums upfront is usually the one with fewer surprises later.