The roof is one of the first big choices on a new home, and in Queensland it usually comes down to Colorbond steel or concrete tiles. Both will do the job for decades if they're installed properly. The differences are in weight, heat, noise, maintenance and looks.

Here's how they compare, without the sales pitch.

Grey weatherboard house with a dark roof, covered front porch and brick steps
Photo by Trinity Nguyen / Unsplash. Roof choice affects heat, weight, noise and upkeep for the life of your home.

The quick comparison

  • Weight: Steel is light. Concrete tiles are roughly ten times heavier, so the roof framing has to be designed for them.
  • Cost: On most project homes the difference is small and can go either way. Ask your builder for the variation cost both ways.
  • Heat: Neither covering insulates much on its own. Colour, sarking or an insulation blanket, and ceiling insulation do the work.
  • Hail: Steel can dent in big hail. Tiles can crack or break.
  • Rain noise: Steel is louder unless you install an insulation blanket under it. Tiles are quieter.
  • Fire: Both are non-combustible.
  • Maintenance: Steel needs very little. Tiles need ridge capping re-pointed and cracked tiles replaced over time.
  • Low pitches: Steel can go on much flatter roofs. Tiles need a steeper pitch.
  • Looks: Down to taste and the style of the house.

Cost

Material, installation and framing costs all move with the market, your roof's size and complexity, and your builder's supply deals. Some builders include tiles as standard and charge extra for steel, others the opposite.

Don't rely on general price claims, including old ones on the internet. Get the variation price both ways from your builder, in writing, before you sign.

Over the life of the house, steel generally costs less to maintain.

Heat and energy efficiency

A thin steel sheet has almost no insulation value, and neither does a concrete tile. What keeps your house cool is:

  • Roof colour. Lighter colours absorb less heat. Colour also affects your NatHERS energy rating, so check with your energy assessor before you fall in love with a dark roof.
  • Sarking or an insulation blanket. Under steel, a foil-faced insulation blanket (Anticon is a common brand) reduces heat, controls condensation and cuts rain noise. Under tiles, reflective sarking reduces heat and stops wind-driven rain and dust getting into the roof space.
  • Ceiling insulation. This does most of the work. Check the R-value in your specification.

Tiles have more thermal mass, so they heat up and cool down more slowly. Steel cools quickly once the sun goes down. In practice, colour and insulation matter far more than the covering.

C8 - Metal Roof, Box Gutter and Flashing Inspection Checklist

$59.00 AUD

Last updated 28 Oct 2026 · Revision 4 · Free updates for life

Checklist Type: Minor

Form Factor: Fillable, print-ready PDF (A4, 31 pages)

When to use: Roofing stage (metal roof), before the linings go in

A 96-point checklist for metal roofs. Check the sheets, screws, laps, flashings, gutters and box gutters before the ceilings are lined, when problems are easier to fix.

Preview C8

See all our checklists

Buy C8 – $59

Hail, wind and storms

Neither is hail-proof. Large hail can dent steel sheets, which usually stay waterproof but look damaged. Large hail can crack or break tiles, which then let water in until they're replaced.

Storm sealing matters with both. On steel, foam closure strips under the sheets and properly turned-up sheet ends stop wind-driven rain getting in. On tiles, valleys need properly cut tiles and a correctly installed valley iron, and the ridge and hip capping must be bedded and pointed properly.

If your house faces into the prevailing storm direction, or you're in an exposed spot, ask your builder how they'll storm seal the roof. Your wind classification also affects how the roof is fixed down.

Fire

Both steel and concrete tiles are non-combustible. On bushfire-prone sites, your BAL (Bushfire Attack Level) rating decides the details: sarking, ember screens, sealing gaps and so on, whichever covering you choose.

Dutch gables and complex roofs

A Dutch gable is a small gable sitting on top of a hip roof. It looks good, but every junction is another place water can get in if it isn't flashed and sealed properly. The same goes for valleys, box gutters and roof-to-wall junctions.

With steel, flashings need to allow for the sheets expanding and contracting with temperature. With tiles, the junctions rely on good flashing and pointing. Either way, the simpler the roof, the fewer places to leak.

Maintenance

Steel: Rain washes most of it clean. Hose down areas sheltered from rain, such as under eaves, periodically, more often near the coast, to keep the coating's warranty valid. Keep gutters clear, and don't let copper pipes or lead flashings drain onto it, as they cause corrosion.

Tiles: Over time the ridge capping pointing cracks and needs repairing, the occasional tile breaks (often from someone walking on it), and moss or lichen can grow in shady spots.

Support structure

Tiles are heavy, so tile roof trusses are designed for the extra load, usually with trusses closer together and more tie-down. Lighter steel roofs need fewer trusses and lighter framing.

On most homes the trusses span to the external walls under either roof. But some internal walls may still carry load, so before you plan any future renovation that removes a wall, check the truss layout with your builder or an engineer. Don't assume.

Roof pitch matters too. Concrete tiles need a minimum pitch, usually around 15 degrees depending on the tile, while some steel profiles can go as low as 1 degree. If you want a skillion or very low-pitched roof, steel is your only real option.

Looks

Colorbond comes in a wide range of colours and profiles, from traditional corrugated to the flatter, wider-ribbed profiles that suit modern homes. Concrete tiles come in flat and curved profiles and a smaller range of colours.

Check estate covenants before you choose. Some estates restrict roof colours or materials.

Changing the colour later

Both can be cleaned and recoated by a specialist roof restorer. Steel recoats well if there's no serious corrosion. Tiles are porous and need proper preparation and sealing before painting. Replacing the whole roof is the expensive option for either. Get quotes at the time, since costs vary a lot.

My advice

Choose based on your house design, your block, your estate rules and your budget. If you go steel, include an insulation blanket and pick a lighter colour if your design allows. If you go tiles, include sarking and make sure the ridges and valleys are done properly.

Whichever you pick, get it inspected before the ceilings go up. My checklists cover what to look for: C8 for metal roofs and C9 for tile roofs, both at constructor.net.au/checklists.